How weird are this year's Country Music Association award nominations?
Pop singer Kelly Clarkson is up for female vocalist of the year, on the strength of a country mix of her Mr. Know It All
single and a duet with Jason Aldean from 2010. The Civil Wars, a folk
duo that almost never gets played on country radio, has a decent shot at
winning at least one of its two nominated categories. Rock and pop
singers wrote three of the five top-song nominees. And rapper Snoop Dogg
appears on what may be the most traditional-sounding country song in
What's going on?
radio and label consolidation, the number of viable artists has shrunk
noticeably over the past couple years," says Chet Flippo, editorial
director at CMT. "It's really obvious that the ranks of good country
artists have been decimated. It's especially affecting women. Radio
doesn't want women artists, labels aren't signing them, and it's showing
up in the charts."
Contending against the likes of Taylor Swift,
Carrie Underwood and Miranda Lambert, Clarkson isn't likely to win her
category Thursday when the 46th annual CMA Awards airs live from
Nashville (ABC, 8 p.m. ET/tape delay PT). And Snoop's nomination -- for a
collaboration with Willie Nelson, Kris Kristofferson and Jamey Johnson
called Roll Me Up and Smoke Me When I Die -- faces stiff
competition from entries by Lionel Richie and Darius Rucker, Kenny
Chesney and Tim McGraw, Alan Jackson and the Zac Brown Band, and Taylor
Swift and the Civil Wars.
But while the Civil Wars are a
dark-horse nominee in the vocal-duo category, a win over Sugarland, Big
& Rich, Thompson Square and Love and Theft isn't completely out of
the question. The duo's Barton Hollow album has gone gold via savvy viral marketing and well-timed television performances.
is quite possible, based on the critical acclaim and their pairing with
Taylor Swift, that the Civil Wars could really make a viable contender
for vocal duo," says Mike Moore, director of country programming at
Entercom Communications in Portland, Ore. However, Moore adds, "I don't
think radio's going to vote for them en masse."
song-of-the-year nominees with pop songwriters all had radio success,
though. Eli Young Band covered Nashville rocker Will Hoge's Even If It Breaks Your Heart. Blake Shelton introduced pop singer/songwriter Dave Barnes' God Gave Me You to a country audience. Dierks Bentley co-wrote Home with
Semisonic-frontman-turned-songwriter/producer Dan Wilson and his
co-producer Brett Beavers. Any of those three might take the trophy in a
category that also includes a song called Springsteen from this year's most nominated artist, Eric Church (with five), as well as Lambert's Over You, which she wrote with Shelton.
songs are all worthy; they all did well from a chart standpoint," Moore
says. "Obviously, people from other worlds are taking note of what's
happening in Nashville."