Becky Herry has tried nearly every drug available for melanoma.
A few years ago, that would have been a very short list. Until
recently, people with advanced melanoma often died within a year of
diagnosis, even with chemotherapy.
For the first time, however, patients such as Herry have options.
The Food and Drug Administration approved two new melanoma drugs in
2011 - the first new therapy for the disease in more than a decade - and
approved two from GlaxoSmithKline on Wednesday. All improve survival by
a few months.
The FDA also has put a Merck melanoma drug,
lambrolizumab, on a fast track to approval by designating it a
Several other drug companies are also working on melanoma therapies.
Melanoma research will take center stage at the four-day annual meeting
of the American Society of Clinical Oncology, which begins Friday in
Chicago. Doctors will present 288 melanoma studies, compared to only 62 a
"The number of new melanoma therapies is sort of
astonishing," says melanoma researcher Lynn Schuchter, a professor at
the University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine. "The pace is
More time, quality of life
No one can
claim to have cured melanoma, the most aggressive form of skin cancer,
which is diagnosed in 77,000 Americans a year and kills more than 9,400.
But after decades of failure, the spate of new drugs is helping more
patients than ever before, giving people like Herry more time and better
quality of life, Schuchter says. Doctors now dare to hope that giving
these new drugs in sequence, or in combination, will help people with
melanoma live for years while feeling relatively good.
traditional chemo, which indiscriminately kills growing cells, the new
generation of melanoma drugs work in a precise way, based on a better
understanding of the specific genes and proteins that drive cancer
growth, says Timothy Turnham, executive director of the Melanoma
"The reason we're seeing these breakthroughs
is because we did the basic science research to help us understand how
this cancer happens, how it escapes therapy and how it progresses,"
Many of the new drugs aim to remove melanoma's
"cloaking device," allowing it to be recognized and killed by the immune
system, says Roy Herbst, chief of medical oncology at the Yale Cancer
Other drugs - such as the two approved Wednesday, trametinib and dabrafenib - target growth signals within cancer cells.
New drugs have fewer side effects
has tried two of the newer drugs from Bristol-Myers Squibb: ipilumumab,
approved in 2011, and an experimental drug called nivolumab.
Although her tumors increased while taking ipilumumab, Herry says a CT
scan earlier this year found they had shrunk by half after beginning
The most noticeable side effects from nivolumab have
been moderate fatigue and vitiligo, a loss of pigment on some areas of
her hands and arms, says Herry, 57, from Santa Cruz, Calif. She's been
able to continue working as a registered nurse throughout these latest
Older melanoma therapies - including interferon,
interleukin-2 and five chemo drugs - caused much more serious side
effects, leaving her too sick to work, Herry says.
When the new
immune therapies work, they often keep cancer at bay for a long time,
says Schuchter, who has patients whose cancer has been controlled by
ipilumumab for three years.
At the cancer meeting, featured
presentations include a study by researcher Mario Sznol, of the Yale
Cancer Center, who will discuss long-term results of nivolumab.
Researcher Stephen Hodi, of Boston's Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, will
present the results of combining ipilumumab with an immune-stimulating
drug. Doctors from New York's Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center
will present research on uveal melanoma, which occurs in the eye, and
affects about 1,200 Americans a year.
Other studies released in advance of the conference have shown positive results.
small study of 69 melanoma patients combined ipilumumab and nivolumab.
In a subgroup of 17 patients, 41% saw their tumors shrink by 80% or
more, says study co-author Jedd Wolchok of New York's Memorial-Sloan
Kettering Cancer Center.
- In a study of 122 patients, a Genentech
immunotherapy shrank tumors in 39% of patients whose tumors made lots
of a particular protein but only 13% of patients whose tumors lacked
this marker. While many of these patients had melanoma, the drug - a
manmade antibody to block a protein called PD-L1 - also helped control
tumors in the lung, kidney, bladder and other organs, Herbst says.
None of the new drugs works for everyone. And none are risk-free.
Ipilumumab can cause severe side effects, created when the immune
system attacks the body itself, Schuchter says. Vemurafenib, approved in
2011, can cause non-lethal skin cancers.
"Doctors will say,
'There are side effects, but they are manageable,'" Turnham says. "Well,
'manageable' can mean something different to patients."
knew a 19-year-old woman with melanoma who "woke up bleeding every
morning" because of rashes caused by one of the new drugs, which targets
mutations in a gene called MEK. The woman died a year later.
Drugs such as ipilumumab can seem like breakthroughs to doctors because
they help 15% of patients. Patients with a limited time to live may not
be so positive, Turnham says.
"If you are a patient and someone
says, 'There is an 85% chance of you spending $120,000 on a drug, and
spending four months of your life being sick, with no benefit,' you're
not going to be so excited."